Multi-Line Claim Supervisor
United States15h ago
Key details
- Salary
- $95K–$105K/yr
- Location
- United States
- Work style
- Remote
- Level
- Senior
- Job type
- Full-time
- Experience
- 8–11 yrs
- Function
- Operations & Strategy
- Focus area
- other
- Posted
- 15h ago
Skills
About the role
This position is listed on behalf of a partner company, who manages all applications and next steps. Our partner is looking for a Multi-Line Claim Supervisor based in the United States.
The Multi-Line Claim Supervisor will oversee complex Property and Casualty (P&C) claims across multiple commercial insurance lines, ensuring high-quality investigations, accurate evaluations, and effective claim resolutions. This role focuses on supervising claim activities for a dedicated client account, covering auto liability, general liability, property, inland marine, cargo, physical damage, and excess liability exposures. The successful candidate will bring advanced expertise in insurance coverage analysis, policy interpretation, and claims management across primary, umbrella, and reinsurance programs. Working closely with claims professionals, clients, legal counsel, and external vendors, this leader will provide technical guidance and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements and service standards. The position also offers opportunities to mentor and develop claims teams while contributing to operational excellence and client satisfaction. This is a remote-reporting opportunity based in the Chicago, Illinois area, with a regular schedule of Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Accountabilities:
-
Review, assign, and supervise multi-line claim activities for designated accounts, ensuring compliance with corporate claims standards, client-specific requirements, and applicable laws.
-
Investigate, evaluate, and adjust assigned claims across multiple lines of commercial insurance.
-
Establish and oversee appropriate claim reserves within authorized limits, ensuring accurate and timely financial assessments.
-
Analyze complex coverage issues involving primary, umbrella, excess, and reinsurance policies, including policy interpretation, coverage position development, attachment point analysis, and coordination with underlying insurers.
-
Provide technical guidance to claims professionals on complex coverage matters involving commercial P&C claims and excess liability programs.
-
Oversee catastrophic losses, severe injury claims, large losses, and complex cases involving multiple coverage layers and stakeholders.
-
Identify, escalate, and manage claims with potential exposure to excess or umbrella insurance programs.
-
Review medical expenses, legal invoices, property damage estimates, and other claim-related costs to determine their reasonableness and relevance, negotiating disputed amounts when necessary.
-
Authorize and process claim payments in accordance with established procedures, industry standards, and assigned payment authority.
-
Negotiate settlements in compliance with claims standards, client-specific instructions, and applicable state regulations.
-
Support claims staff in selecting, referring, and supervising external vendors, including legal counsel, surveillance providers, and case management specialists.
-
Direct the handling of designated litigated and technically complex claims.
-
Provide training, technical education, and professional development support to claims team members.
-
Maintain accurate claim documentation, manage personal claim diaries, and ensure timely file reviews.
-
Oversee all multi-line claim activity for assigned client accounts, maintaining service quality and accountability.
-
Ensure consistent adherence to claims handling standards, contractual obligations, and specific client requirements.
-
At least 8 years of Property and Casualty claims experience, including hands-on experience handling multiple commercial insurance lines.
-
Strong claims handling expertise in:
-
Auto liability.
-
General liability.
-
Commercial property.
-
Umbrella and excess liability claims.
-
Inland marine, cargo, and physical damage claims preferred.
-
Demonstrated experience analyzing coverage under primary, umbrella, and excess insurance policies.
-
Strong understanding of commercial insurance policy interpretation, coverage investigations, reservation of rights, coverage position development, and complex multi-line loss exposures.
-
Ability to evaluate complex coverage scenarios and identify potential indemnity and defense obligations.
-
At least three years of supervisory or team leadership experience preferred.
-
Bachelor's degree preferred.
-
Strong knowledge of claims handling responsibilities across multiple levels and insurance lines.
-
Excellent analytical, problem-solving, and negotiation skills.
-
Strong written and verbal communication skills, with the ability to communicate effectively with clients, claimants, insureds, legal counsel, vendors, and internal teams.
-
Demonstrated ability to establish and achieve performance objectives while maintaining high service standards.
-
Strong organizational skills, attention to detail, and the ability to coordinate and prioritize multiple responsibilities.
-
Ability to work independently, adapt to changing priorities, and perform effectively in a fast-paced environment.
-
High level of professionalism, discretion, confidentiality, and accountability.
-
Strong customer service orientation and responsiveness to internal and external client needs.
-
Proficiency in Microsoft Office applications.
-
Adjuster license where required by applicable jurisdiction.
-
AIC, CPCU, or ARM designation preferred.
-
Spanish bilingual proficiency is highly valued but not required.
-
Experience managing claims for large commercial insureds with layered insurance programs, including excess and reinsurance structures, is an advantage.
-
Reliable attendance and availability during established client service hours.
-
Annual salary ranging from $95,000 to $105,000, depending on qualifications, experience, geographic location, and internal equity.
-
Potential eligibility for bonuses or additional compensation.
-
Four weeks of paid time off, accrued throughout the year in accordance with company policy.
-
Ten paid holidays during the first year of employment.
-
Comprehensive medical, dental, and vision insurance.
-
Life and disability insurance coverage.
-
401(k) retirement savings plan.
-
Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP).
-
Internal training and professional development opportunities.
-
Opportunities for career advancement and progression into management roles.
-
Supportive, collaborative, and team-oriented work environment.
-
Employee ownership culture that encourages accountability and professional growth.
-
Remote reporting arrangement.
-
Regular Monday-to-Friday schedule, from 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
The Multi-Line Claim Supervisor will oversee the investigation, adjustment, and management of assigned commercial Property and Casualty claims, ensuring consistent service quality and compliance with client-specific instructions and established claims standards. The role combines technical claims expertise, supervisory responsibilities, coverage analysis, and settlement negotiation.
Requirements:
The ideal candidate is an experienced commercial claims professional with extensive knowledge of multi-line Property and Casualty insurance and a strong background in complex coverage analysis. They combine technical expertise with supervisory capabilities, sound judgment, and excellent communication and negotiation skills. The successful candidate will be comfortable managing competing priorities, supporting claims teams, and maintaining strong relationships with internal and external stakeholders.
Benefits:
How well do you match this job?
Free account needed to apply or save. It takes a minute, and we'll bring you right back to this job.